the pros and cons of building a granny flat3

The Pros And Cons Of Building A Granny Flat

Granny flats, or secondary dwellings , have been increasingly popular as a practical and attractive option for homeowners hoping to increase their property's utility and worth. Advantages abound in these separate dwellings, usually on the same property as the main house. Yet, like with any major renovation, there are a few things to consider and some negatives to be aware of.

Insightful consideration of the benefits and drawbacks of constructing a granny flat has been included in this guide to help readers make an informed decision about this adaptable housing option. This all-encompassing summary will give you the information you need to make a well-informed decision, whether you want to increase your property's rental potential, living space, or footprint. Come along as we explore the many facets of this unique housing choice, discussing the advantages and disadvantages as we go.

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    What Is A Granny Flat?

    The term "granny flat" refers to a room or area of a property renovated so that an elderly person can live alone.

    A granny flat is typically constructed in a location such as the garage or the attic. This allows the occupant to sense that they are not in the way and are not occupying a precious area in the main house.

    The construction of a granny flat may have certain advantages, but it also has certain drawbacks. 

    Different Types Of Granny Flats

    the pros and cons of building a granny flat2

    There are a variety of names for granny flats, such as mother-in-law suites or secondary suites, apartments, or casitas. Granny flats are also sometimes referred to as secondary suites. As long as they are completely separate from the primary residence, they are referred to as an secondary dwellings, in the official terminology. In most cases, they come equipped with a private bedroom, bathroom, kitchen, living area, and door leading directly into the unit. 

    They come in a variety of forms and dimensions, and they can either stand alone or be integrated into the primary residence:

    • Tiny home: Tiny houses are perfect for children in their teenage or early adult years, and even older relatives may be able to live comfortably in one. Depending on the circumstances, they are less likely to require permits than larger new buildings.
    • Converted garage: One of the most typical and practical approaches to building a granny flat is to transform an underutilised garage. It is conceivable to construct a second story on top of the garage even if it is still used.
    • Converted attic: not necessarily the best choice for senior relatives or guests, but perfect for older children or other guests.
    • Converted basement: Converting a basement into a living space is another popular option; when it has its exterior entrance, it is simple to keep the space distinct from the primary residence.
    • New building: The most expensive alternative is to construct a brand-new building, which is also the option that may be the most challenging to obtain permits for.

    Pros Of Building A Granny Flat

    The construction of a granny flat, also known as an extra living unit, can benefit homeowners. These detached dwellings have grown in popularity due to their adaptability and possible advantages, even though they are located on the same site as the primary residence. We'll go through the advantages of building a granny flat and how it can improve your home and way of life. Let's explore the strong arguments in favour of this useful improvement, from increased resale value to more adaptable housing options.

    Make Your Space Versatile.

    There are several advantages to having a dedicated area in your own house. Depending on the composition of your household, it could serve as a teen hangout, a guest bedroom, or a sanctuary for the parents. These days, more individuals than ever before are working from home, making a granny apartment the ideal solution for separating work and family life.

    Living Arrangements That Are More Flexible

    Granny flats have historically been utilised as secondary dwellings for elderly relatives. They've also grown in popularity as a way for parents to help their children live independently while they save up for their places. You may use a granny flat for more than just housing a relative or a nanny; it can also serve as a place to do business.

    A Multi-Generational Space

    Relatives who are elderly can enjoy a greater sense of security, eliminate the need to rely on residential care facilities and enjoy more time with their families. Or, they may build a granny apartment and move into it themselves, allowing their grown child to use the main house for a new family. In this way, young children can be cared for, and senior loved ones can rest assured that they will be provided for as they age. There will be fewer expenses for child care and nursing home stays if the family is able to stay together.

    You Could Even Become An Airbnb Superhost (Or A Landlord).

    You could generate more revenue by renting it out. At the same time, not all states permit public rentals of granny flats, those that can provide a nice supplement to your income with little hassle.

    The return on investment for properties with granny flats can be substantial in areas where they are allowed. A granny flat that costs $120,000 to build would break even at a $300 weekly rental rate in just over seven years.

    You will have to accept that you will be living close to your tenant; however, this proximity might work out for the best. You might get to know a new person on a more personal level.

    Increased Property Value

    Costing roughly $130,000 to complete, a well-executed granny flat addition can significantly raise the resale or investment potential of your primary residence.

     

    If you're considering constructing one, be sure the work is done properly, or it could decrease your home's value. That's why it's important to consider your property's current aesthetic as you develop your granny flat.

    It Is Possible To Rent Out

    No rule states a granny flat must be kept within the family; in fact, many people use them as a way to generate additional income from spaces on their property that they are not utilising. These kinds of units are frequently available for either long-term or short-term rental.

    There Are Numerous Low-Cost Options For Constructing A Granny Flat.

    Since granny flats have recently become popular, many variations can be chosen. The price ranges from under $30,000 for a prefab kit to over $120,000 for a fully completed, plumbed, and powered suite. 

    The actual resale value may be far more than the initial price. They can be designed with private bathrooms, kitchenettes, and even decks for hosting casual dinner parties because the benefits shouldn't be limited to the buyer after you. You can finance the expansion of your business by tapping into the equity already present in your home, or you might look into getting an additional loan or a top-up on your existing mortgage.

    Additional Rental Income

    Whether you're considering constructing a granny flat on your residence or as an extension to your investment property, renting it out to long-term renters or through a service like Airbnb generates significant additional income.

     

    Before you develop, consider the privacy needs of yourself and any future renters of your investment property. For your and your granny flat tenants' peace of mind, consider installing an extra route leading to the granny flat from the street.

     

    If you want to use your granny flat as a rental unit, you should verify the legality of doing so in your state.

    Cons Of Building A Granny Flat

    Although there are many gains from constructing a granny flat, there are also a few negatives to consider. There are various factors to consider, as there would be with any housing selection. To assist you in making a well-informed decision, we'll look at the cons of building a granny flat in this section. 

    When Renting A Granny Flat, There Are Tax Implications.

    Additional parking, pooling energy expenses, and mutual agreement to forego karaoke nights are all simple solutions to some potential drawbacks of renting out your granny flat. However, tax implications must be carefully considered.

    Making money from a granny flat can cause your primary residence to be viewed by the ATO as a rental property rather than a primary residence, which could result in a higher tax bill when it comes time to sell the property.

    The Process For Approval

    You will need to go through the same permission process as you would for any other major home renovation before building your granny flat. While regulations may differ from state to state, a certifier and minimal paperwork are required for a "complying development" property.

     

    Properties that don't fit that description may require a more involved procedure. You should factor in more time for this because you'll need to submit a comprehensive development application.

    Upkeep And Maintenance

    Granny flats, like any other type of property, need to have routine maintenance performed on them. When calculating the total cost of ownership, it is important to consider expenses such as those for landscaping, repairs, and utilities.

    You May Be Lowering The Value Of Your Home.

    Potential purchasers may be put off by the presence of granny flats and outbuildings, especially if they are older and have not been updated in decades. Take care to maintain its condition. When it's time to sell, treat it as any other room in your house, with new paint, flowers, and no hidden exercise equipment.

    Before you start researching council laws or buildings, you can get a sense of the finished product by visiting a showroom or display of granny flats. Keep in mind that the way you put it to use is flexible and can develop over time, even after you've reached the grandparent stage of life.

    What Is The Cost Of Constructing A Granny Flat?

    the pros and cons of building a granny flat1

    Adding a granny flat to an existing home can add anything from a few thousand to a few hundred thousand dollars, depending on location within Australia and the dwelling's size and amenities.

    If you are considering having a new granny flat built on your property, you should anticipate spending somewhere between $100,000 and $150,000 for the project.

    Have a clear budget and see if the following costs are included in the cost of your granny flat build before you decide to build your granny flat.

    • Building materials
    • building plan/design
    • fixtures and fittings.
    • labour and tradespeople
    • surveying and engineer reports
    • Permits and certifications for planning and construction

    Is There A Granny Flat Alternative?

    There is an option for a granny flat that you might consider if a granny flat has all the advantages and benefits that you require, but you want to avoid any of the disadvantages. A granny annexe, often known as a granny suite, is similar to a granny flat in appearance but does not have the same cons.

    A granny flat is a separate living quarters attached to a main house, typically in the backyard. This means that you can be close to your family and friends and be there for them when they need you, without confining them to your home.

    An elderly person will feel right at home in a granny annexe because it has all the amenities of a modest house but is scaled down to suit their needs. Your loved one can live a full and satisfying life without you interfering, and they can rely on you and your family whenever they have questions or need assistance.

    Conclusion 

    Granny flats, or secondary dwellings, are a popular and practical option for homeowners looking to increase their property's utility and worth. These separate dwellings, usually located on the same property as the main house, offer advantages such as increased resale value, living space, and footprint. There are various types of granny flats, including small homes, converted garages, attics, basements, and new buildings.

    Tiny homes are perfect for children in their teenage or early adult years, while larger new buildings may require permits. Converted garages can be transformed into a second story on top of an underutilized garage, while attics are ideal for older children or guests. Converting a basement into a living space is another popular option, as it allows the space to remain distinct from the primary residence.

    The construction of a granny flat can benefit homeowners by making their space versatile, serving as a teen hangout, guest bedroom, or sanctuary for parents. With more people working from home, granny apartments are an ideal solution for separating work and family life. They can also serve as a multi-generational space, providing a sense of security for elderly relatives and allowing them to spend more time with their families.

    Granny flats can also be used as Airbnb superhosts or landlords, generating more revenue by renting out the property. However, not all states permit public rentals of granny flats, which can provide a nice supplement to income with little hassle. The return on investment for properties with granny flats can be substantial in areas where they are allowed, with a $120,000 building costing $120,000 to build breaking even at a $300 weekly rental rate in just over seven years.

    A well-executed granny flat addition can significantly raise the resale or investment potential of your primary residence. However, it is important to consider your property's current aesthetic when developing a granny flat.

    In summary, granny flats are a practical and attractive option for homeowners looking to increase their property's utility and worth. They come in various forms and dimensions, and can either stand alone or be integrated into the primary residence. The advantages of building a granny flat include increased resale value, more adaptable housing options, and the ability to create a multi-generational space. However, it is crucial to ensure that the work is done properly to avoid potential negatives and maintain the property's current aesthetic.

    A granny flat is a popular and affordable way to generate additional income from unutilized spaces on your property. There are numerous low-cost options for constructing a granny flat, with prices ranging from under $30,000 for a prefab kit to over $120,000 for a fully completed, plumbed, and powered suite. The actual resale value may be far more than the initial price, and they can be designed with private bathrooms, kitchenettes, and decks for hosting casual dinner parties.

    Renting out a granny flat to long-term renters or through services like Airbnb generates significant additional income. Before building, consider the privacy needs of yourself and any future renters of your investment property. For your and your granny flat tenants' peace of mind, consider installing an extra route leading to the granny flat from the street.

    However, there are some cons of building a granny flat. When renting out, there are tax implications, as making money from a granny flat can cause your primary residence to be viewed by the ATO as a rental property rather than a primary residence, which could result in a higher tax bill when it comes time to sell the property.

    The process for approval for a granny flat involves going through the same permission process as any other major home renovation. A certifier and minimal paperwork are required for a "complying development" property, while properties that don't fit that description may require a more involved procedure.

    Upkeep and maintenance are essential for a granny flat, and potential purchasers may be put off by the presence of granny flats and outbuildings, especially if they are older and have not been updated in decades. It is important to maintain the condition of the property and treat it as any other room in your house when it's time to sell.

    To get a sense of the finished product, visit a showroom or display of granny flats before researching council laws or buildings. The cost of constructing a granny flat can range from a few thousand to a few hundred thousand dollars, depending on location within Australia and the dwelling's size and amenities.

    An alternative option for a granny flat is a granny annexe, also known as a granny suite, which is similar to a granny flat but does not have the same cons. A granny annexe is a separate living quarters attached to a main house, typically in the backyard, allowing you to be close to family and friends without confining them to your home.

    Content Summary: 

    • Granny flats, or secondary dwellings , have been increasingly popular as a practical and attractive option for homeowners hoping to increase their property's utility and worth.
    • Advantages abound in these separate dwellings, usually on the same property as the main house.
    • Yet, like with any major renovation, there are a few things to consider and some negatives to be aware of.
    • Insightful consideration of the benefits and drawbacks of constructing a granny flat has been included in this guide to help readers make an informed decision about this adaptable housing option.
    • This all-encompassing summary will give you the information you need to make a well-informed decision, whether you want to increase your property's rental potential, living space, or footprint.
    • Come along as we explore the many facets of this unique housing choice, discussing the advantages and disadvantages as we go.
    • The term "granny flat" refers to a room or area of a property renovated so that an elderly person can live alone.
    • A granny flat is typically constructed in a location such as the garage or the attic.
    • This allows the occupant to sense that they are not in the way and are not occupying a precious area in the main house.
    • The construction of a granny flat may have certain advantages, but it also has certain drawbacks.
    • There are a variety of names for granny flats, such as mother-in-law suites or secondary suites, apartments, or casitas.
    • Granny flats are also sometimes referred to as secondary suites.
    • As long as they are completely separate from the primary residence, they are referred to as an secondary dwellings, in the official terminology.
    • In most cases, they come equipped with a private bedroom, bathroom, kitchen, living area, and door leading directly into the unit.
    • They come in a variety of forms and dimensions, and they can either stand alone or be integrated into the primary residence: Tiny home: Tiny houses are perfect for children in their teenage or early adult years, and even older relatives may be able to live comfortably in one.
    • Depending on the circumstances, they are less likely to require permits than larger new buildings.
    • Converted garage: One of the most typical and practical approaches to building a granny flat is to transform an underutilised garage.
    • It is conceivable to construct a second story on top of the garage even if it is still used.
    • Converted attic: not necessarily the best choice for senior relatives or guests, but perfect for older children or other guests.
    • Converted basement: Converting a basement into a living space is another popular option; when it has its exterior entrance, it is simple to keep the space distinct from the primary residence.
    • New building: The most expensive alternative is to construct a brand-new building, which is also the option that may be the most challenging to obtain permits for.
    • The construction of a granny flat, also known as an extra living unit, can benefit homeowners.
    • These detached dwellings have grown in popularity due to their adaptability and possible advantages, even though they are located on the same site as the primary residence.
    • We'll go through the advantages of building a granny flat and how it can improve your home and way of life.
    • Let's explore the strong arguments in favour of this useful improvement, from increased resale value to more adaptable housing options.
    • There are several advantages to having a dedicated area in your own house.
    • Depending on the composition of your household, it could serve as a teen hangout, a guest bedroom, or a sanctuary for the parents.
    • These days, more individuals than ever before are working from home, making a granny apartment the ideal solution for separating work and family life.
    • Granny flats have historically been utilised as secondary dwellings for elderly relatives.
    • They've also grown in popularity as a way for parents to help their children live independently while they save up for their places.
    • You may use a granny flat for more than just housing a relative or a nanny; it can also serve as a place to do business.

     

    Frequently Asked Questions About Granny Flat

    Yes, it is possible to build a granny flat on most properties. However, it's crucial to know local zoning laws and regulations that may dictate specific requirements and restrictions. These regulations vary from one area to another, so it's essential to conduct thorough research and, if necessary, consult with local authorities or planning departments to ensure compliance before proceeding with the construction of a granny flat. This will help avoid any potential legal complications in the future.

     

    Apart from their traditional use as living spaces for family members or rental units, granny flats offer a range of creative possibilities:

    • Home Office or Studio: Transform your granny flat into a productive workspace, providing a quiet and separate area to focus on work or creative projects.
    • Guest Suite: Create a comfortable and private space for visiting friends or family members, offering them a home away from home.
    • Fitness or Yoga Studio: Design the space to accommodate exercise equipment or yoga mats, promoting a healthy and active lifestyle.
    • Airbnb Rental: Generate additional income by listing the granny flat on platforms like Airbnb for short-term rentals.
    • Student Accommodation: Provide a cosy living space for students, offering them a comfortable and independent environment.
    • Aging in Place: As a future investment, the granny flat can accommodate elderly family members, ensuring they have their own space while staying close.

    When financing the construction of a granny flat, you have various options. These include home equity loans, which leverage the value of your property, specialised construction loans tailored for building projects, and the possibility of refinancing your existing mortgage to access the necessary funds.

     

    Embracing sustainability in your granny flat design is environmentally conscious and economically beneficial. Consider integrating eco-friendly elements such as solar panels to harness renewable energy, opting for energy-efficient appliances to minimise consumption, and utilising sustainable building materials to reduce environmental impact.

     

    While it's possible to design a granny flat yourself, hiring a professional designer can ensure optimal use of space and compliance with building codes.

    Scroll to Top